Monday, September 23, 2019

Journal 2- Estrogen

This study focused on the effect estrogen might have on anxiety-like behaviors within paternal mice and the role it might have on hippocampal neuroplasticity. With the hippocampus playing an important role in the stress response it was very interesting to see how they were able to perform this experiment and interconnect anxiety-like behaviors and neurogenesis within the hippocampus. The researchers discussed how the expression of ER beta receptors is elevated during mid-postpartum, indicating an increase in binding sites available for estradiol. In addition, these higher levels of estrogen increase adult neuroplasticity and more specifically enhances paternal neuroplasticity 16 days postpartum.  
TMX (a receptor estrogen modulator) was also used within the experiment. This treatment found to impair neurogenesis in paternal mice but not in virgins, which further indicated that estrogen plays an important role in neuroplasticity in fathers. However, TMX did not have an effect on anxiety-like behavior, which I would have thought the TMX would have decreased estrogen levels and increased anxiety-like behaviors. It would be interested to see if another test besides the EMP would show an increase in anxiety-like behaviors. 
It was interesting to see the sex differences within this experiment and would definitely be great to read what sort of things contribute to neuroplasticity in woman and also in what hormones contribute to anxiety-like behaviors. A question I had was if this study had to do with just how postpartum impacts fathers and mothers (also the stress of being a parent)? Or in a larger sense stress in general? I think it would be interesting to see how different stressors might contribute to the neuroendocrine system and also how these hormones are within certain disorders. In addition, oxytocin and vasopressin were said to have been observed. I am unsure exactly what the data in the study was saying about those, but I am wondering how they might influence one another and also impact these findings as well. 

Journal Club 2 - Response


Overall, I thought this paper was a more focused look at a specific topic relating to paternal neuroendocrine function and had fewer experiments that were tailored to the researchers’ hypothesis. The assays were more specific compared to the last paper we read and had fewer variables to manipulate and test for. This made for a slightly more in-depth study, with specific conclusions drawn from limited assays, as opposed to the last paper, which was broader and had more of a wider range of results and experiments. I thought that this was appropriate, as the previous paper seemed a bit more exploratory, while this paper was supported by previous experiments with similar results.
However, one issue I had with this paper was its use of figures and tables – specifically, in the way they listed some statistical information regarding their behavioural assays in table format. It made it very difficult to read and understand, and I think graphs with error bars would have made for easier reading rather than having to parse through the columns of the tables. In addition, I thought their results section was very statistic-heavy, using words like ‘significant interaction’ and ‘main effect’ that I thought were harder to put into context. This made it hard to interpret the results of the experiments, leaving me confused about what they were actually able to prove. I understood eventually that this was just the nature of the experiment, and that some of the assays they ran had a different effect between virgins and parents – for example, in the administration of the tamoxifen drug, there were different responses between parents who did and did not receive the drug as well as differences between controls and parents who did receive the drug. This ‘double result’ assay made for a little bit harder interpretation, but eventually I was able to understand what the authors were talking about (I think, I could be completely wrong).
            Another issue I had with the study was the number of animals that they needed to exclude from analysis for a variety of reasons, whether it was brain slices that needed to be excluded from assays, or poor behavioural responses from animals that led to them being removed from analysis. While I understand that problems may occur throughout experimentation, they had n values as high as 13 being excluded from particular studies, which made me wonder whether there was a bigger issue to be addressed with the assays that were being used. In addition, when it came to their estradiol concentration assay, the authors write that ‘concentrations did not meet assumptions of normality’ and decided to normalise the values instead. If there was also an issue with the estradiol quantification, I would again question their assay of choice rather than normalise the values to find results. Together, these results make me slightly worried about the care that the authors put into choosing assays, and whether or not they were fishing for results and changing the way they analyse data.

Journal Club 2- Estrogen-dependent pathways in mediating neurogenesis

This paper outlined an interesting link between the endocrine and nervous systems, ultimately proving the potential for estrogen-dependent pathways in mediating hippocampal adult neurogenesis. It addresses this using a unique sample population as most mammalian species do not involve males in the parenting process. Unsurprisingly, parental postpartum behavior is often researched using the female brain while male postpartum behavior is not very researched on its own.  What I found fascinating about the results of these experiments was that despite having no role in parturition and lactation, they undergo similar neuroendocrine changes that accompany parenthood as females do. Furthermore, the fact that this paper addresses the neuroendocrine mechanisms underlying paternal experience-related hippocampal plasticity and suggests a parallel between the female and male brains is groundbreaking. 
Investigating Figure 1, I was surprised to see that paternal experience reduced prlr expression.  I was puzzled to see that the levels of prolactin, a hormone that binds to this receptor and involved with lactation were so high in the male virgin control group. I wonder how prolactin works to onset parental care and why its levels drop immediately postpartum. It would be interesting to perform similar experiments further examining the role of this hormone and what affect, if any, it may have on neuronal plasticity. 
What I also found interesting was that while there seemed to be a step-wise decline in estradiol levels from PND2 to PND30, an upregulation in ERB relative gene expression was observed at PND16. This is not what I expected as if the levels of estradiol are declining for most of the postpartum period, why is it that receptor expression for the hormone is so high? I assume that this may further affirm the claim that estradiol has a greater purpose than guiding parental behaviors in the postpartum period, and may very well enhance structural plasticity within the hippocampus.  It is also possible that activation of these receptors at PND16 may have underlied the increased adult neurogenesis observed in the saline-treated fathers since this effect was not observed in theTMX-treated fathers of experiment 2. It would be interesting to replicate this study using other selective estrogen related modulators to see whether these mechanisms may possibly be related to hormone-dependent cancers. 
The experimental design for experiment one was well thought out and the method of reverse RNA transcription and qPCR amplification was well controlled, with the efficiency of each primer and probe determined taken into consideration. However, something that I noted was that the standard deviations for the data in experiment one are fairly large.  Expression of Esr2 at PND16 had a variance of 0.23 which is about half of the mean, 0.44. The mean for Esr2 expression at PND30 was also about twice the value of the standard deviation, making the data very variable. This may be due to the very small sample sizes in this experiment.  For example, some hippocampal samples did not yield usable RNA in experiment one and were excluded from analyses, resulting in varied sample sizes across gene expression analyses. Had more mice been used in the experiments, I believe that the results would provide more precise and meaningful data. 
Although the paper noted two other studies suggesting that estradiol may support adult neurogenesis in the DG of parentally-behaving rodents, there are still many unanswered questions regarding the role of enhanced circulating estradiol and upregulation of specific estradiol receptors on the patterns of neurogenesis. Despite this, the paper proved that changes in estrogen receptor expression affect neurogenesis in fathers but not in virgin males. This important link between hormones and the brain points to a new avenue of research within neurogenesis as well as highlights the potential for possible treatments of hormone-related diseases. 

02 Second Group Journal Club: Estrogen-dependent modifications to hippocampal plasticity in paternal California mice (Peromyscus californicus)

This paper studies the effect of estrogen-dependent mechanism on neurogenesis and anxiety-like behaviors. The main focused area of the brain was hippocampus; more specifically, the dentate gyrus (DG). In the paper, they explain that the DG is the brain region involved in the mediation of anxiety, and extensive neurogenesis in adults is observed in that region.

The experiment was really in two parts: 1) measuring the expression of ERβ, which is an estrogen receptor, and 2) determining the role of the estrogen-dependent mechanism when it comes to neurogenesis and anxiety-like behavior.

One fact that was new to me was that hippocampus is a brain region that is a potent site of estradiol activity. Also, estrogens having a role in cell proliferation and cell survival was something new and interesting. The paper touches on the basics of neuron activity by mentioning how the activation of the ERβ (receptor) is necessary for the estradiol (neurotransmitter) to have the anxiolytic effects.

Regarding the experimental design, I did not quite understand the purpose of timing some of the procedures, including the time from cervical dislocation to liquid nitrogen. Also, I wonder if there was a specific reason to dissect out the brain directly following the EPM behavioral testing other than preventing further modifications in the brain before the dissection.

From the charts, the first thing that caught my attention was the drop in the expression of Prlr. The paper, towards the end, mentions that the prolactin also has anxiolytic effects and can promote the survival of newborn neurons. It was intriguing to see how different anxiolytics hormones are playing a role depending on which stage the animal was in; prolactin plays a role in reducing anxiety preparing for the offspring, not after.

Another part of the study that I had a question was the aromatase enzyme part. This paper does study the effect of an increase in the estradiol due to the aromatase activity, but I wonder if there were effects of reduced testosterone level on the paternal behavior since the estradiol increase is from the conversion of testosterone to estradiol through aromatization.

Lastly, it was interesting to see how a more invasive method of giving treatment, in this case, TMX, might have caused alteration to the study; this reminded me of how there are pros and cons of giving medications in a less invasive, such as medication dissolved in the water, from previous journal club paper.

Journal Club 2: Estrogen-dependent modifications to hippocampus in paternal mice

This paper was novel in that it observed circulating estradiol and hippocampal ER-beta gene expression in paternal mice, and claimed to be the first to suggest a relationship between estrogen-dependent mechanisms and neurogenesis in the hippocampus in paternal mice. In the group's first experiment, they measured gene expression of ER-beta, an estrogen receptor, and receptors of other parenting-related hormones in virgin males and fathers during different points in the postpartum period. The experimental design involved pairs of mice being housed together, either as a male-male pair or a male-female pair. This might be a stretch, but I wonder if this design of male-male pairing could have in any way affected hormone receptor levels as a result of characteristic male behaviors. The researchers found that ERbeta expression was highest in PND16 fathers as compared to PND2 and PND30. Circulating estradiol was found to be highest at PND2, then decrease in a stepwise manner at PND16 and PND30. This makes sense, as an increase in receptors would allow for more estradiol binding resulting in decreased circulating estradiol. 

In the second experiment, mice were separated into three groups: handled, saline-treated, and TMX-treated. However, the n was quite small for a number of the groups, including various treatment groups. The handled mice were only handled for 10 seconds per day, while the treatment groups were injected daily with either TMX or saline. I would argue that during these daily injections, the mice endured the same amount of stress as did the handled mice. The mice were then assessed for anxiety-like behavior in the Elevated Plus Maze Task. Seven mice were excluded from the data following this task including those that were immobile for >40% of the time, though I wonder if this type of behavior might also be an indicator of anxiety. In general, I think there are a lot of factors that could influence exploratory behavior and that this behavioral assay should be taken with a grain of salt.

In regard to the proliferation of cells in the dentate gyrus, I'm curious as to why Figure 4 shows a significant increase in % of co-localization between BrdU+ and Tuj1+ cells in the saline-treated fathers as compared to saline-treated virgins but there is no significant increase in the number of BrdU-labeled cells between these groups in Figure 3. I was also confused as to why the number of proliferating cells can be directly compared between paternal mice and virgins -- if fatherhood begets neurogenesis, then wouldn't you expect more proliferating cells? In other words, I feel like Figure 3 should have been presented as a percentage of proliferating cells instead of absolute numbers in case the rate of neurogenesis is different between paternal mice and virgins. Overall, I think the paper did a convincing job of showing that there is neurogenesis in the hippocampus of paternal mice mediated by estrogen and its receptor which is not present in virgin mice. 







Journal Club 2-- Estrogen-dependent modifications to hippocampal plasticity in paternal mice


In this paper, the impact of estrogen on hippocampal neurogenesis and anxiety-like behaviors was studied in paternal mice. Gene expression of estrogen receptors, how estrogen changes anxiety-like behaviors, and estradiol levels were examined. While the study was clearly about male mice, “fathers”, I would have been very interested to see the experiment done with female mice as well. I think it would have been fascinating to compare the two, as they were sure to be different, and also see if both sexes reacted the same way to experimental interference.

In the paper’s results we can see that there was a higher expression of the ERβ gene, which codes for an estrogen receptor, in mid-postpartum mice fathers than in fathers in early or late postpartum periods, or in virgin mice. The result that virgin mice have less estradiol than early post-partum fathers also means that estradiol may be implicated in paternal behaviors, which I thought to be quite interesting. Additionally, while past research has shown estrogen reduces anxiety-like behavior, this study did not find this result when examining fathers treated with TMX vs fathers treated with saline or virgin mice. This was particularly interesting, and makes me want to see both this and those past studies replicated to collect additional sets of data.

Despite that result, the idea that estrogen has an impact upon anxiety-related behaviors, makes me wonder if utilizing the neuroendocrine system may one day be an effective anxiety treatment. It also made we wonder about what this means for any individuals utilizing hormonal birth control, and possible connections this may have to mothers who suffer from post-partum depression.

Regarding points of confusion, I am looking forward to going over Table 3 in class. I understand that Table 3 was portraying the maze performance of mice after experimental treatments, but did struggle a little with comprehending exactly what all of the numbers in the table meant. I did appreciate the use of bold text to show what was statistically significant, but the rest did result in some confusion. None the less, most of the other figures were well presented and comprehensible.


Estrogen-dependent Modifications to Hippocampal Plasticity


This was an interesting article about neuroendocrinology that focused not just on neural differences between sexes, but differences based on experience, which I found particularly interesting. The article explores the relationship between behavioral induced estrogen dependent neuromodulation and anxiety like behavior.
The introduction introduced relevant brain regions as well as previous studies that have found relationships between parental behavior and neuroplasticity. The introduction also introduced estrogen receptors and their role in cell proliferation, referencing rat cell proliferation and meadow voles. I am curious whether these rodents have similar responses to estradiol, and particularly if there are differences in the male’s responses as I do not know whether male rats and voles partake in parental care.
Within the methods section I was confused by the hippocampi being “homogenized” before the nucleic acid isolation I had never encountered this before. I was also not how exactly the elevated plus maze task was measure the mouse’s anxiety. It seems like all mice would have elevated anxiety if removed from their cages and placed in an unfamiliar maze environment, and their response to the anxiety might just be different.
I definitively found the figures in this article more clear than those in the article last week. In figure 1A it was interesting that there was not difference in ESR2 between virgin mice and PND2 and PNDE30 fathers. It seems like this receptor upregulation is very time specific. Also, I was surprised that the prolactin receptor expression was significantly higher in the virgin mice, especially because the discussion talks about prolactin levels being elevated in California mouse males on PND2. I also found it curious that the elevated circulating estradiol levels in the paternal mice on PND2 did not coincide with the elevated estrogen receptor mRNA. It would be interesting to see how early the ESR2 level rise and before PND 16.
It was surprising that there was no main effect of parental experience on BrdU labelled cells in the DG but then there was a significant difference between fathers treated with TMX and virgins treated with TMX. I don’t really understand why the raised estradiol levels and ESR2 levels would not cause an increase in BrdU labelled cells in fathers, but then modifying the estrogen receptors disproportionately influences fathers.
I was definitively confused by some of the methods and results, but overall this was a very interesting article.

Journal Club 2 -- Estrogen and Hippocampal Plasticity in Fathers

Overall, I enjoyed this paper and thought it quite simply demonstrated what the main research questions were, and exactly which results were obtained. From what I gather, fathers showed increased neurogenesis compared to virgins and a decrease in anxious behavior, and the hippocampal plasticity was attenuated by TMX treatment in paternal (but not virgin) mice. These results provide support that estradiol modulates the neuronal changes seen in the hippocampus.

I do think the paper was very statistic analysis heavy, which is definitely one of my weak points when interpreting data. For this reason, I am confused about the two tables in the paper. Table 2 is a little more straight forward than Table 3, and since the results section states that no interactions were seen for the data in Table 2, I am able to interpret that treatment with tamoxifen (TMX) did not have significant impact on paternal behavior as a whole. 

However, I am having a hard time deciphering what is significant and what isn’t in Table 3. I would have liked to see the information in a figure rather than a table. Are the results showing that being a father reduced anxiety-like behavior, but treatment with TMX returned the anxiety-like behavior similar to that of the virgin group? This is the result I would expect, based off of the presumed function of TMX as an estrogen receptor modulator. I would definitely benefit from going over this Table in class!

Additionally, I am a little unsure about what the weight analysis in Figure 5 adds to the study at hand. I understand how changes in weight can be indicative of endocrine changes, but I couldn’t quite grasp how this played in to the study of estrogen and/or anxiety during fatherhood. Why exactly would virgin mice show an increased weight throughout the experiment, but fathers wouldn’t? Additionally, why did the experimental treatments cause increases in weight in fathers, but the same treatments did not show increased weight in virgins? 

I found this study very interesting though, because hormones following childbirth is one of the few topics that has been primarily studied in females, and very rarely in males. I think it is just as important to see how these hormonal changes alter males, so that researchers have a comprehensive understanding of the functions and consequences of estrogen in the body. Perhaps with more studies such as this, we can have a better understanding of how human fathers respond emotionally and biologically to both childbirth and fatherhood. 

Sunday, September 22, 2019

Journal 2: Estrogen-dependent modification to hippocampal plasticity in California mice


This paper attempts to find unique relationship between two body systems, the nervous and endocrine systems. They investigated the extent of neuroendocrine functions on hippocampal neurogenesis and on anxiety-like behaviors in paternal California mice. Past studies have shown that estradiol increases cells in the dentate gyrus in the hippocampus in females and males and reduces anxiety like behaviors in mid-postpartum period. The extent to which this occurs in unclear so Hyer et al. aimed to this by measuring gene expression of estrogen receptors and other parental hormones in male virgins and fathers, quantifying circulating estradiol concentrations, and by studying how estrogen changes effect anxiety like behaviors in these mice.
Their results show that higher expression of Ers2, a gene that encodes ERβ, an estrogen receptor, in fathers in the mid-postpartum period as compared to virgin mice and fathers in the early- and late- postpartum periods. This indicates an increase in these receptors in the hippocampus in fathers only. Hyer et al. also found that virgins had less circulating estradiol compared to fathers during the early-postpartum period, and this decreases at later postpartum periods. This may indicate that estradiol supports the onset of paternal behaviors and less so later on. Additionally, the authors found no differences in anxiety like behaviors between virgins and fathers who have been treated with saline or tamoxifen (TMX), a selective estrogen receptor modulator that blocks estrogen binding to estrogen receptors. Past studies have shown that estrogen reduces anxiety like behaviors, but this finding did not show this. Furthermore, TMX-treated paternal males had fewer BrdU-labeled cells and colocalization of BrdU and Tuj-1 than TMX-treated virgins. Among saline treated mice, paternal experience increased the percentage of colocalization. These results show that neurogenesis in adult males with parental experience in mediated by estrogen-dependent mechanisms, because without estrogen signaling, less neuroplasticity occurred, and also paternal experience showed increased neurogenesis compared to virgins. Lastly, Saline and TMX treated fathers weighed less at baseline compared to time of BrdU injection, time of treatment, and time of perfusion. This was also seen in handled, saline treated, and TMX treated virgins, but not seen in handled fathers.
Hyer et al. had shown that neuroendocrine functions are taking place in paternal mice and aid in hippocampal plasticity. They however were not able to show differences in anxiety-like behaviors between handled, saline treated, or TMX treated virgins and fathers. This may be due to the injection protocol, which called have cause stress to the animals. Changes in weight gain between saline and TMMX treated mice were since after the injection protocol, which may be an indication of an altered endocrine state or added stress to the animals. Instead of showing decreased anxiety like behaviors in non TMX treated mice, anxiety like behaviors may have remained the same because of added stress as a result of daily injections.
I found this paper very interesting because Hyer et al. discovered more relationships between two bodily systems, and also sought to study estradiol functions male rats, which is often only reserved to female mice. These studies show that paternal mice also go through hormonal changes postpartum and they further aimed to see to what extent these changes affect neuroplasticity. However, even though there were past studies using female mice that study postpartum hormonal changes, I think that they should have also compared their results to female mice counterparts, instead of just between virgin males and fathers. This data may give more insight on differences between hormonal functions between males and females during different postpartum periods.
I would like to see future studies on how estrogen could be a possible treatment for anxiety, since past studies has seen a rescue effect of estradiol in anxiety-like behaviors. Additionally, since selective estrogen receptor modulators like TMX compete with estradiol to bind to estrogen receptors, these drugs could have a harmful effect on anxiety like behaviors. Lastly, the authors could try to create a different protocol that would prevent mice from getting more stressed from the actions of the protocol itself. This could remove a confounding variable that effected their results. Overall, I would like to see more studies that show how other bodily systems could either improve or worsen behaviors caused by the nervous system.