This paper attempts to find unique relationship
between two body systems, the nervous and endocrine systems. They investigated the
extent of neuroendocrine functions on hippocampal neurogenesis and on
anxiety-like behaviors in paternal California mice. Past studies have shown
that estradiol increases cells in the dentate gyrus in the hippocampus in females
and males and reduces anxiety like behaviors in mid-postpartum period. The extent
to which this occurs in unclear so Hyer et al. aimed to this by measuring gene
expression of estrogen receptors and other parental hormones in male virgins
and fathers, quantifying circulating estradiol concentrations, and by studying
how estrogen changes effect anxiety like behaviors in these mice.
Their results show that higher expression
of Ers2,
a gene that encodes ERβ, an estrogen receptor, in fathers in the mid-postpartum
period as compared to virgin mice and fathers in the early- and late-
postpartum periods. This indicates an increase in these receptors in the
hippocampus in fathers only. Hyer et al. also found that virgins had
less circulating estradiol compared to fathers during the early-postpartum
period, and this decreases at later postpartum periods. This may indicate that
estradiol supports the onset of paternal behaviors and less so later on.
Additionally, the authors found no differences in anxiety like behaviors
between virgins and fathers who have been treated with saline or tamoxifen
(TMX), a selective estrogen receptor modulator that blocks estrogen binding to
estrogen receptors. Past studies have shown that estrogen reduces anxiety like behaviors,
but this finding did not show this. Furthermore, TMX-treated paternal males had
fewer BrdU-labeled cells and colocalization of BrdU and Tuj-1 than TMX-treated
virgins. Among saline treated mice, paternal experience increased the
percentage of colocalization. These results show that neurogenesis in adult
males with parental experience in mediated by estrogen-dependent mechanisms,
because without estrogen signaling, less neuroplasticity occurred, and also
paternal experience showed increased neurogenesis compared to virgins. Lastly, Saline
and TMX treated fathers weighed less at baseline compared to time of BrdU injection,
time of treatment, and time of perfusion. This was also seen in handled, saline
treated, and TMX treated virgins, but not seen in handled fathers.
Hyer et al. had shown that
neuroendocrine functions are taking place in paternal mice and aid in hippocampal
plasticity. They however were not able to show differences in anxiety-like
behaviors between handled, saline treated, or TMX treated virgins and fathers. This
may be due to the injection protocol, which called have cause stress to the
animals. Changes in weight gain between saline and TMMX treated mice were since
after the injection protocol, which may be an indication of an altered
endocrine state or added stress to the animals. Instead of showing decreased
anxiety like behaviors in non TMX treated mice, anxiety like behaviors may have
remained the same because of added stress as a result of daily injections.
I found this paper very interesting
because Hyer et al. discovered more relationships between two bodily systems,
and also sought to study estradiol functions male rats, which is often only reserved
to female mice. These studies show that paternal mice also go through hormonal changes
postpartum and they further aimed to see to what extent these changes affect
neuroplasticity. However, even though there were past studies using female mice
that study postpartum hormonal changes, I think that they should have also compared
their results to female mice counterparts, instead of just between virgin males
and fathers. This data may give more insight on differences between hormonal
functions between males and females during different postpartum periods.
I would like to see future studies
on how estrogen could be a possible treatment for anxiety, since past studies
has seen a rescue effect of estradiol in anxiety-like behaviors. Additionally,
since selective estrogen receptor modulators like TMX compete with estradiol to
bind to estrogen receptors, these drugs could have a harmful effect on anxiety
like behaviors. Lastly, the authors could try to create a different protocol
that would prevent mice from getting more stressed from the actions of the protocol
itself. This could remove a confounding variable that effected their results.
Overall, I would like to see more studies that show how other bodily systems
could either improve or worsen behaviors caused by the nervous system.