Overall, I did like this article. Frequently, scientific publications will detail very complex experimental procedures in a way that can be difficult to understand without a very strong background in that specific field. I found that this was not the case for this article. The methods were clear and concise, stating how the mice and rats were housed, stress induced, and which behavioral and biochemical measures were analyzed. I would have been interested in more information regarding why the tricyclic antidepressant imipramine was chosen for the pharmacological treatment of the mice over other potential antidepressants. Due to the lack of information of the reasoning behind this choice, I can only assume that it was selected due to ease of access or past research I am not familiar with.
I do have quite a few questions regarding areas of the article past the methods. In the first results paragraph, the article mentions that “surprisingly, CUS-exposed mice exhibited decreased numbers of microglia in the hippocampal DG”. This surprised me, too, and I don’t exactly understand how or why this would be the case. Is it possible that there was a decrease in microglia due to the rodent’s bodies essentially giving in to the stress and no longer responding as they would have to acute stress? Or would this be a potential avenue of further study; studying numbers of microglia at different weeks of CUS-exposure? I’d also be interested in further study of glia after more than five weeks of CUS exposure. It is mentioned that in past research, where studies used shorter periods of stress exposure, microglial activation was found instead of suppression. I think it would be fascinating to see if that suppression plateaus at any point, or if microglia get continually and increasingly suppressed over time. Or, conversely, if the brain ever attempts to rebound or work against the suppression given enough time, which seems unlikely but should at least be ruled out.
Regarding major points of confusion, I’d appreciate talking through the figures in class. I didn’t really understand what m through r in Figure 3 was displaying. Or, rather, exactly why the expression of the IL-1 gene was relevant in the context of the figure, which I interpreted to be the impact of microglia on the measured stress-induced depressive behavior. Was the relevance of the IL-1 gene due to the IL-1 cytokine’s ability to mediate the effects of stress?
All these questions aside, I thought the focus of the research was certainly very interesting. Especially since, not too long ago, scientists dismissed glia as having little importance when it comes to cognition and impacts upon behavior. I believe that this article did accomplish the goal of demonstrating that stress changes microglia activity in mice, and ultimately results in depressive symptoms. I think a similar study in primates, as their social and depressive behaviors are very comparable to those of humans, is a good potential next step for this research and field.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.