Tuesday, December 3, 2019

05 Sixth Journal Club: Positive mood on the day of influenza vaccination predicts vaccine effectiveness: A prospective observational cohort study


This study was interesting since it is one of the first studies on the effect of psychological and behavioral factors on vaccine-induced protective antibody response in the elderly “using a robust method.” However, there were some clear limitations to the study.

The very first point that I wanted to bring up was the fact that the strain of the vaccine that was used in the study was the same strain as the vaccination of the previous year. Although they did mention this in their discussions section, I wonder if they were able to repeat the study where the vaccination strain was different; also, the fact that all three strains remaining in the vaccine the same happened only twice, previously, was very interesting.

Another question I had was the I-PANAS-SF test simplification. The paper states that the assessment was shortened to make it less burdensome. I was wondering if this is something that occurs frequently in studies involving mood measurements. If not, would this lower the accuracy of the positive and negative mood measurement, which was the focus of this study.

Overall, I thought this paper is a great start to study the effects of behavioral and psychological factors on influenza vaccine in elderly, but there definitely are improvements that can be made.

First, the sample used for this study was very specific to one race. They did mention it in the paper, and when I double-checked the numbers, 97.8 percent of the sample was Caucasian. Although this would have made sense if the study was focusing on Caucasian, because the study was for the general elderly population, the sample being nearly 100 percent Caucasian puts a huge limit to the study.

Second, the study is diary-based. Although there really is no way of keeping track of individual behavior of every single individual for 6 weeks, the fact that the behavioral data were all collected by diary makes it difficult for me to "buy" it. Especially because the study is on the elderly, the diary entry may not be as accurate as the researcher want them to be.

Lastly, I wanted to bring up the figures in the study. The paper is made up mostly of tables. This made it fairly difficult to understand what they wanted to present because every measurement they collected were included.

Monday, December 2, 2019

Journal Club 5

I found this type of paper interesting, as the researchers seem to admit that they were simply looking at numerous different factors that may influence flu vaccine outcomes. Most papers we read have hard, concrete hypotheses, whereas this one first gathered all the data and then looked for relationships between the variables to come to their conclusion. I appreciated how much thought went in to the project with all the background research they conducted and used to base their findings off of. However, I really did not "buy" the fact that positive mood on the day of vaccination increases the protective effects of the vaccine.

To start, basing half of the research project off of self-reporting diary entries that participants completed only three times a week leaves a lot of things unaccounted for. After working in a sleep research lab, I saw firsthand just how unreliable participant diaries can be, especially in regards to mood and perceived sleep quality. Mood is very subjective, and many individuals have different thresholds for what they consider "sad", "content", or "happy". Additionally, it is extremely difficult to track exactly what time you fall asleep, how long it takes to fall asleep, how many times you wake up at night, etc. These things combined can produce a large source of error into the data set. For that reason alone, I don't believe that a claim as strong as "positive mood on the day of vaccination is a significant predictor of seroprotection" can be made from the type of data collected.

This effect was also only found with the H1N1 strain, which is the least immuno-activating strain the group studied. Although interesting that this correlation is not seen with greater immune-activating strains, I would like to see additional follow-up evidence on why that may be happening before I believe that positive mood has any sort of influence.

All in all, I think this study could have benefited from measuring some other indicators of "mood" and stress. They mentioned in the paper that the group of participants were all relatively happy individuals, with very few reporting any stress or negative affect during the study period. Perhaps looking at something like waking cortisol or other blood hormones would be useful in gathering a more complete picture at exactly which factors are having the greatest influence.

Affect and vaccination response


This study made a very interesting claim on a critical topic in healthcare. Besides the known fact that vaccinations should not be given to anyone experiencing a fever, I never thought of patient behaviors and psychological well-being as having an influence on vaccination effectiveness. Furthermore, I was surprised to learn that affect can be a significant predictor of H1N1 seroprotection and IgG responses post-vaccination. Although I believe that mood shapes immunological responses, this study does not show a clear, direct correlation between affect and vaccination responses. These beneficial effects of positive affect were not found for the H3N2 and B strains of the vaccination. Future experiments should further investigate the findings made in this study.  
One indirect biological explanation for this relationship is that people with positive moods generally live healthier lifestyles which is associated with a stronger immune system. The paper also touched on prior research linking positive affective states to CNS parasympathetic activation, cortisol secretions, as well as other mechanisms linked to the endocrine system, which as we learned interplays with the immune system. 
I thought that the general outline of the experiment was strong due to being a prospective, diary-based longitudinal study, although I still have some questions with how this experiment was conducted. The study was performed from August 2014 to March 2015, which although is prime flu season, also coincides with many other illnesses. It’s possible that other illnesses or upregulation of the immune system had an effect on the H1N1 seroprotection levels. It’s also possible that people who suffered a cold or any other illness during this time may have experienced less positive mood, therefore causing these decreased IgG levels in those with more negative mood on vaccination day. Furthermore, they excluded participants with cognitive disorders, although I think it would have been interesting to see if there is any correlation between the vaccine-induced protective antibody response and affect, as well as anxiety or fear. It would have been useful to include exactly what kind of cognitive disorders were excluded. 
Another interesting aspect of the study was that the vaccine strain they used for testing was identical to that of the previous year, meaning that many participants had already received the vaccine in the past. In fact, they mentioned that a substantial proportion of participants reached seroprotection thresholds for the H3N2 (63.1%) and B (47.2%) strains of the vaccine at baseline and I wonder whether this prior elevation in protective antibodies affected the results of this study. Finally, although this study has clinical relevance, it would be difficult to implement the findings into a real-life setting. Changing the affect of a person in order to increase the effectiveness of a vaccination would be difficult, especially in those suffering from depression or other cognitive dysfunctions.



Immune Modulators Influenza Vaccination

I thought this paper was quite different from the ones we have previously read, in that it was quite exploratory and broad. I thought the premise of the study was interesting, especially considering the amount of background reading that the authors had done – it seemed like most of the results were confirming results that had been seen in other studies, and yet they still referred to this study as exploratory. I also thought the method of data collection was interesting. The authors defended their use of the diary method, saying that it was better than ‘retrospective self-report measures’, but I still think that this method leaves lots of room for error since they are asking participants to record every day. For the mood and affect data, it seems likely that a participant may have forgotten or made up a recording because they were busy or lazy, and this could skew results more than if the participants were simply asked to be reflective at a doctor’s appointment. However, I do think that this method was better for the dietary and sleep data, since that can be harder to remember over the course of many days. I also appreciated the authors’ explanations as to why they collected the data at the time points they did, and their reporting of data that was missing to show that there was in fact data missing that was insignificant and not attributable to any specific reason. 
As for how much I ‘buy’ their results, I think they should be taken with a grain of salt. Positive and negative affect are measures that can be difficult to really quantify and measure since they are mostly abstract and vary greatly from person to person. For the authors to report that this measure, positive affect, was the only factor that had an impact on vaccination outcome seems shaky at best. Additionally, their potential reasoning that this could be caused by endocrine or lymphatic innervation seems questionable. If there was an endocrine reason, would this not be reflected by hormones or other endocrine signaling molecules in the blood samples of the participants? If the lymphatic system were innervated by the CNS, why were the results not similar across all different strains? This also brings me to another point, that which the authors note that the vaccination that the participants were receiving was the same exact vaccination that they had gotten the year before. This, to me, really invalidates the whole point of the study, seeing as some of the participants already had seroprotective levels of IgG in their blood prior to the vaccination as part of this study. How can the authors say that they are measuring the effect of the vaccination when it was mostly redundant at the time of the study? I think it would have been more beneficial to study the effects of these immune modulators on at least one novel strain, but that was not possible in this study. For that reason, I believe that this study should be repeated before results stating that ‘greater positive mood […] significantly predicted greater antibody responses to the influenza vaccination’ are to be believed.

Journal Club 5: positive mood on day of influenza vaccination

Within the article, the researchers sought to determine whether a positive mood on the day of vaccination would increase the effectiveness of the vaccine. Their objective was to observe the effects of multiple behavioral and psychological influences on the effectiveness of the immune response to influenza in adults 65 years of age and older.

What the researchers saw was that the greater the mood in older adults, particularly on the day of vaccination, the more the body effectively responded to the vaccination. I thought this was a particular interesting article, especially because there it is one of the first studies to examine all behavioral and psychological immune modulators and how they might influence vaccination responses simultaneously.

At first glance, the study I thought would be difficult to test all behavioral and psychological immune modulators being that there are so many different factors. In measuring positive and negative mood I thought it was interesting that they only assessed their mood based on four responses in the diary period, 2 positive and two negative, I would think that it would not be enough to determine an individuals over all mood to be positive of negative. In addition, because the data collected is from the individual themselves the information given could be biased. Another problem I saw was that all of the individuals were from the same area. Racial and genetic factors could also play a role in the immune response. Lastly, I feel like it might be difficult to fully say whether the vaccine is effective if the individual is not exposed to the influenza virus.

There were a couple things I was confused about in the experiment. I had a hard time figuring out how they merged all the data together and well as Figure 3. I think an interesting factor that could have added in is exercise since they discussed another study found that exercise before a vaccination showed greater post-vaccination antibodies. Lastly, I thought it was interesting that only the weakest strain, H1N, and the relationship between positive mood and antibody responses was observed. It would be interesting to see what factors might increase the effectiveness of H3N2 and B immunogenic strains.

Effects of behavioral and psychological factors on immune response to influenza vaccination

This paper sought to determine whether behavioral factors like physical activity, nutrition, and sleep, and psychological factors like stress, positive mood, and negative mood, influenced the effectiveness of the immune response to an influenza vaccination in elderly subject. A self-reported survey was used to measure these factors, beginning from two weeks pre-vaccination until four weeks post-vaccination. Immune response was measured at 4 and 16 weeks post-vaccination. The study found that greater positive mood, both over a 6-week period and on the day of vaccination, predicted greater antibody responses to the vaccination only in the  H1N1 viral strain.

I like the idea behind this research study, but I feel as though the execution could have been better. The researchers tried to assess the effects of six different behavioral and psychological factors, all of which could vary and interact to influence results. Since the data was self-reported, many biases could have also modulated results. Based on the demographical data given, the cohort of people used in the study was probably not representative of the general older adult population, especially since the sample was self-selected. It could be true that people who are willing to participate in such a research study are able to do so because their socioeconomic status, health status, and other factors allow them. These are factors which also can affect a person's mental health including positive and negative affect, which were measured in the study. The researchers found a low prevalence of stress and negative affect within the cohort, which I believe could have been a result skewed by the types of individuals who elected to be in the study.

Overall, I don't think I buy the idea that positive mood increases immune response from an influenza vaccine. The measures seems too subjective to draw any large conclusions from. Perhaps if the study had used participants who weren't so uniform, the researchers' conclusions would seem more valid.