Tuesday, November 5, 2019

Pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in adulthood


In this paper, Koomogorova et al tested if immune challenges during puberty had effects on memory in adulthood. This research used mice, both male and female. The mice were injected with LPS or saline at six weeks, and then three weeks later either had a gonadectomy, ovariectomy, or a sham surgery. At mice adulthood of ten weeks, mice were put through behavioral testing including the Barnes maze, open field, and Morris water maze. At seventeen weeks, brain tissue was collected so cells in the subgranular zone, CAI, and CA3 of the hippocampus could be studied.

The data of this experiment did should some clear differences between female and male mice in cognitive tasks, something that I thought was particularly interesting. To me, this is especially of note as it should be considered when planning and analyzing further mice research, if replicable. There were also differences in data between mice that were and were not treated with LPS. It appeared that gonadectomies did not result in changes in cognitive behaviors in male mice.

Results also showed that LPS in puberty had a negative effect on HPC-dependent tasks later in life, but only in low stress conditions. This result was come to, as performance in the low-stress Barnes maze was affected, but not the high-stress Morris water maze. This finding confused me, and I’m not sure exactly what the researchers were looking for, or trying to find through, through using and comparing both of the two mazes.

I enjoyed this paper, as this is not a research topic that I’ve ever been presented with or read about in the past. The results of this study and future related studies could be incredibly important for understanding immune challenges and the impact they can have upon cognition in later years. I did not understand why the researchers chose nine weeks for the gonadectomy/ovariectomy, and seventeen weeks to collect brain tissue from these mice. I can only assume that nine weeks is considered to be after puberty, but the time seems somewhat random. Additionally, with the chosen time for brain tissue collection. I would have liked to see some rational behind those decisions.

Monday, November 4, 2019

Pubertal Immune Stress


Within this study, Kolomogorova et al. examines whether or not an immune challenge during puberty would have sex-specific memory deficits behaviorally and cellularly in the hippocampus. LPS was used to induce stress, and gonadectomy to regulate gonad-derived hormones such as estrogen and progesterone. I found this study to be quite interesting and informative. I was unaware that there are sex differences in memory and how stress can impair memory. The researchers found that neurogenesis and proliferation were not affected by LPS treatment or gonadectomy, which makes me wonder what mechanisms could be behind these differences.
In addition, researchers found that learning deficits were more prominent during the Barnes maze test. This made me wonder what the differences between each test it is about the Barnes maze test that lead to most cognitive deficits. In addition, the researchers tested levels of sickness and body weight of the mice and I wasn’t sure as to what their reasoning was behind these tests. I also thought it was interesting that they studied the mixed strategy use in males and females for the Barnes maze test. I wasn’t sure exactly what they meant by that and how/why they gathered data on the section of the experiment. To add on, they performed these tests on the mice for four days and was unsure what their reasoning was for doing so.
I thought it was interesting that they used behavioral tests to show the link between stress and cognitive deficits. One thought I had was why they did not measure levels of corticosterone or other levels of sex hormones such as progesterone and estrogen. They mentioned that to test for mice in estrous phase they used a smear to measure, however, the levels of estradiol or other hormones wasn’t mentioned, and I wasn’t sure if they would be something to consider adding into the paper. Overall, I found this study to be very interesting and gained more knowledge on this topic. I’m interested to see other studies that build upon this one in other treatments that impact aspects of hippocampal neurogenesis.

Pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in T adulthood

In this paper, Kolmogorova et al. address the link between pubertal immune activation and cognitive function. I find this topic very novel and interesting as I did not know that memory may be impacted by immune system triggers such as stress. Moreover, I was intrigued by their finding that some of these effects are sex-specific, as it may point to how differences in the way males and females process stress may make one sex more prone to cognitive dysfunctions. I was surprised to see that that pubertal immune challenge elicits similar learning impairments in females and males when given low stress spatial memory tasks, but not in high-stress memory tasks. I would instead expect pubertal immune challenge, combined with high-stress, to lead to cognitive impairments. Furthermore, they showed that these mechanisms are not modulated by gonad-derived hormones or changes in basal neurogenesis which points to the question as to what mechanisms are driving these differences.
Something I noticed was that in each of the four experimental groups of mice in this experiment, all of the mice completed the open field test, the Barnes maze (BM), and the Morris water maze (MWM) in that order, over five weeks. I wonder why this particular order of behavioral tasks was chosen and I wonder whether the mice would behave the same had the order been randomized. The paper even mentioned that several other  studies have demonstrated that the extent of OVX-induced impairments in adult rodents differ between hippocampus-dependent tasks. Furthermore, although they were trying to minimize the carry-over effects of the prior test, I think that five weeks is a long time span within development, during which the cognitive function of the mice may change. I think it would have been better to test from a greater sample of mice, separated into groups which each group exposed to one type of behavior task, followed by across-group comparisons. 
In addition, I believe that no change in weight in the mice following LPS injection may not have been a great indicator of uncharacteristic LPS tolerance. Instead, a sickness behavior may have been exhibited in those animals, just not in the form of weight loss. Therefore, the mice exhibiting no significant weight loss should not have been excluded from the study. 
I thought their finding that gonadectomy impaired learning during the Morris water maze in both sexes was interesting. Because this test involves a level of stress, they were able to show that stress-dependent expression of LPS-induced cognitive deficits. Although a researcher would normally like to control for such variables, because they also tested the mice with other behavior tests, this experimental design was appropriate. What this paper did not prove, however, was the direct physiological link between stress and cognitive learning.  In addition, although they proved that the experiental mice exhibited sex-specific changes in cellular proliferation of neurons inin the CA1, a region involved in detecting spatial novelty and episodic-like memory, I wonder what features of neurogenesis may bee prreesent in brain regions involved with other cognitive tasks. 

Pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in adulthood

In this study by Kolmogorova et al, researchers aimed to establish whether exposure to an immune challenge during puberty would induce sex-specific deficits in behavioral and cellular indicators of hippocampus-dependent memory during adulthood. To do this, both male and female CD-1 mice were injected at six weeks of age with either saline or LPS to induce an immune response. Three weeks following, the mice were subjected to either gonadectomy or sham surgery. Then at ten weeks, the mice were subjected to a variety of behavioral tests including the open field, Barnes maze, and Morris water maze paradigms. Brain tissue was later collected at 17 weeks to examine cellular proliferation in the subgranular zone, CA1, and CA3 regions of the hippocampus.

The group concluded that LPS treatment during puberty impaired learning during adulthood in both male and female mice, but that hormonal modulation through gonadectomy did not mediate or alter any of these observations. The researchers also asserted that because learning deficits were more prominent in the Barnes maze than in the Morris water maze, LPS-induced cognitive impairments must have stress-dependent expression. They stated that LPS treatment seems to impair performance during low-stress (Barnes maze) but not high-stress (Morris water maze) conditions. I wasn't quite clear on what the purpose of using the Morris water maze was in this study, especially considering their mentioning that rat-based findings using this paradigm can't be translated to mice. I wasn't sure if their intention was to compare low-stress vs high-stress situations, or if this was a conclusion drawn after the study was completed as a way to explain differential behavior observed between the paradigms.

One question I had about the paper was whether the authors ever made any mention of group sizes (maybe I missed them?). Another question was why they chose 9 weeks for the gonadectomy and 17 weeks to collect brain tissue. The timing of both of these procedures was certainly a key factor in seeing results, so I wonder whether having completed these at different time points would have led to different observations. Lastly, I was wondering whether male and female mice go through puberty at the same time during their lives. In humans this is obviously not the case, so I wonder if differential pubertal timing in mice could have altered the effects of the LPS treatment and gonadectomy. Maybe time points for these procedures should actually be different between male and female mice?

Pubertal Immune Stress and Spatial Memory


This week I read the article titled “pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in adulthood.” The article described an experiment looking for a link between pubertal stress exposure via, LPS, gonad-derived hormone modulation and cognitive spatial memory processing. The introduction does a good job at describing the important activational effects of sex hormones as well as the influence of immune stress during development and how these two may interact.
I found it interesting that this article addressed the age of the mice when they were transported to the lab, and that it stated that the age was resistant to the enduring effects of shipping stress. Given the amount of studies that have linked adolescent stress to later cognitive or psychiatric impairment, I wonder how valid this is. I also wonder why this was not addressed in any of the previous studies which we read, and if it could have influenced those results.
With the Barnes Maze, I am unsure of the purpose of placing the mice in the opaque chamber and exposing this to aversive stimuli, when the test also aimed to “reduce potential anxiety.” I am also slightly confused as to why both the Barnes Maze and the Morris Water Maze were used. I suppose that it would be good to have two experimental measures, but they both seem to measure spatial memory. Additionally, could the cognitive flexibility assessed by the MWM just as easily have been assessed by reversing the BM? This would avoid the additional stress which is caused by the MWM which has been shown to influence learning/navigational behavior. Maybe this would be worth trying if the experiment were repeated/replicated.
Most of the results seemed somewhat confusing to me. For example in the open field test, LPS-SHAM females cover significantly less distance than SAL-SHAM females, but yet move at a significantly faster pace. The data for the Barnes maze was also slightly confusing. The maze graphs were slightly complicated to read, with the significance of differences between the groups being denoted by letters on a line graph.
I was initially surprised by the results of the MWM especially given the effects of LPS on the BM performance, but possible explanations for this were addressed in the discussion. The results of the MWM also mostly lined up with the cellular expression data, which showed that most of the Ki67 and DCX expression in the hippocampus was not significantly different between groups. It was definitively good to read a paper were the main hypothesis was largely not found to be true, as I am sure this is the case more often than I realize.

04 Fifth Journal Club: Pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in adulthood


This study was about the alteration of spatial memory processes induced by pubertal immune stress. This paper was especially interesting because not many of the papers that I read in the past were about memory development.

When reading, one of the first questions that I had, which was a question I had last week, was the difference in dark and light phase behavioral studies. For this study, all behavioral tests were run during the dark phase with red light, and I was wondering if there is an advantage of doing behavioral studies at dark phase; the only reason I could think of was that rodents are generally nocturnal, but they tend to sleep in short bursts.

Also, in the result section, they stated that “LPS-SHAM females were slower and traveled less than SAL-SHAM and LPS-OVX females and their male counterparts.” However, from Figure H, I noticed that LPS-SHAM traveled faster than both saline groups. I was wondering if I was misinterpreting the chart or the paragraphs. Overall, the results section was very difficult to follow when reading, but the charts did a great job visualizing them.

Also, they included observation of the estrous stage for the female rats but did not discuss it in the paper other than briefly explaining the charts/diagrams.

Another point that caught my attention was their explanation for the discrepancies between BM and MWM. They stated that the possible cause of the discrepancies of BM and MWM behavioral tests was that dry-land BM is less stressful compared to MWM and could have elucidated learning and navigating behaviors more than MWM. I am currently modifying my approach for a grant proposal, and one of the problems that I am having is the effect of behavioral test induced stress on the performance of the behavioral test; there are very small number of behavioral tests for depressive-like behaviors, and most of them induce stress on the animal in different ways. Their explanation shows how there still are ways to go with behavioral tests.

Pubertal Immune Stress Journal Club

This study by Kolmogorova et al. first looked at whether a pubertal immune challenge by LPS influences hippocampal development and function in adulthood. Additionally, the group looked at the regulatory links between gonadal steroid hormones and hippocampus dependent memory functions after pubertal immune challenge. This was achieved by injecting pubertal mice with either LPS or saline (control), and then subjecting them to either gonadectomy or sham-surgery 3 weeks later. All mice groups were then evaluated by behavioral testing in the Barnes maze and Morris water maze to determine the extent of influence on spatial learning memory.

Overall, the researchers hypothesized that the LPS exposure during puberty would indeed produce sex-specific effects on hippocampus-dependent memory in adulthood, and that gonadectomy would impair cognitive performance in both sexes. The researchers determined that during low-stress spatial memory tasks, immune challenge by LPS during puberty impairs learning in both sexes, with females showing greater impairments in cognitive flexibility than males. However, LPS administration did not produce learning deficits in high-stress conditions and appear to occur independently of gonadal hormone influences. Additionally, males also show more sensitivity to LPS-priming of CA1 cellular proliferation than females, but LPS-induced changes in hippocampal neurogenesis was not seen in either sex. Overall, the findings did not support the initial hypothesis that gonadal steroid hormones impact performance or regulate the cognitive effects seen after pubertal LPS exposure.

One thing that immediately stood out to me about this study was the estrous phase determination by vaginal smear. The researchers noted the percentage of females in each phase and actively recognized that estrous cycles may impact the various measures they were testing based on previous research, but never looked specifically at whether performance differed depending on which phase the mice were in. Perhaps sampling them all together, rather than teasing apart individual differences, was used to show that when sampled as a group, no major differences in performance exist between estrous phases and that it is not a source of major variability to the extent that other papers believe it to be. However, I believe that the results would have benefited from including an additional figure depicting the performance of the females broken down by estrous phase. Perhaps no significant differences would be found, but I think establishing that fact is especially important when  conducting research specifically pertaining to sex differences. 

Sunday, November 3, 2019

Pubertal immune stress transiently alters spatial memory processes in adulthood


Kolmogorova et al. wanted to test if pubertal immune stress can alter cognitive and memory ability in mice in adulthood, and if gonadal derive hormones modulate these processes. Sexual dimorphisms exist between cognitive ability due to gonad-derived hormones, and LPS exposure has been shown to impair various function including recognition memory. Kolmogorova et al. further wanted to find if these two factors were related.
Mice were exposed to LPS or saline at 6 weeks (pubertal stage) and at 9 weeks, they underwent gonadectomy, ovariectomy, or sham surgery. At 10 weeks, when mice were adults, they completed open field test, Barnes maze (BM) and Morris water maze (MWM) over 5 weeks. Vaginal smears were collected during learning and probe phases of BM and MWM. Brain tissue was collected 2 weeks later to examine differences in hippocampal neurogenesis and cellular proliferation. Results show some distinct difference between males and females in the cognitive tasks, differences in cognitive task between mice that were treated with LPS versus those treated with saline, and no impact of gonadectomies on cognitive behaviors. Pubertal LPS treatment appears to impair HPC-dependent task performance in adulthood during low stress but not high-stress conditions. BM is less stressful than MWM and results show LPS impairs performance mice only in BM. Females were better in acquisition and retention tasks in MWM while males were better in spatial retention tasks. Neither pubertal immune challenge nor gonadectomy affected basal expression and co-labeling of DCX+ and Ki67+ cells in SGZ. However, Intact males exposed to LPS during puberty expressed more Ki67+ cells in the CA1 than their saline-treated and castrated counterparts while female counterparts showed no differences. Overall, Kolmogorova et al. showed that pubertal immune challenge elicits similar learning impairments in females and males on low stress hippocampal spatial memory tasks and is not modulated by gonad-derived hormones or changes in basal neurogenesis.
  I found this paper very interesting because it studies a concept I have never read up on before. it talks about how immune challenge could cause cognitive deficits later in life. Findings on this topic may explain how early life stress and infection could cause learning deficits later in life. Additionally, I found it interesting that female mice are better in some cognitive tasks than males and vice versa. I would like to see more studies that explore more of their differences and how immune challenge can negatively affect cognitive development. Additionally, I did not understand why this study didn’t further explore estrous phases in female mice and how they performed on the mazes. Certain stages may or may not influence differences in cognitive ability. In conclusion, this concept was new to me and I would like to see more studied on this topic that could bring more insight on causes and treatments for cognitive impairments.