Overall, I enjoyed this paper and thought it quite simply demonstrated what the main research questions were, and exactly which results were obtained. From what I gather, fathers showed increased neurogenesis compared to virgins and a decrease in anxious behavior, and the hippocampal plasticity was attenuated by TMX treatment in paternal (but not virgin) mice. These results provide support that estradiol modulates the neuronal changes seen in the hippocampus.
I do think the paper was very statistic analysis heavy, which is definitely one of my weak points when interpreting data. For this reason, I am confused about the two tables in the paper. Table 2 is a little more straight forward than Table 3, and since the results section states that no interactions were seen for the data in Table 2, I am able to interpret that treatment with tamoxifen (TMX) did not have significant impact on paternal behavior as a whole.
However, I am having a hard time deciphering what is significant and what isn’t in Table 3. I would have liked to see the information in a figure rather than a table. Are the results showing that being a father reduced anxiety-like behavior, but treatment with TMX returned the anxiety-like behavior similar to that of the virgin group? This is the result I would expect, based off of the presumed function of TMX as an estrogen receptor modulator. I would definitely benefit from going over this Table in class!
Additionally, I am a little unsure about what the weight analysis in Figure 5 adds to the study at hand. I understand how changes in weight can be indicative of endocrine changes, but I couldn’t quite grasp how this played in to the study of estrogen and/or anxiety during fatherhood. Why exactly would virgin mice show an increased weight throughout the experiment, but fathers wouldn’t? Additionally, why did the experimental treatments cause increases in weight in fathers, but the same treatments did not show increased weight in virgins?
I found this study very interesting though, because hormones following childbirth is one of the few topics that has been primarily studied in females, and very rarely in males. I think it is just as important to see how these hormonal changes alter males, so that researchers have a comprehensive understanding of the functions and consequences of estrogen in the body. Perhaps with more studies such as this, we can have a better understanding of how human fathers respond emotionally and biologically to both childbirth and fatherhood.
Agreed that the study of fatherhood is interesting and refreshing! Let's talk about the tables/ stats in class--I don't think you were the only one who struggled with understanding those effects
ReplyDelete