In the second experiment, mice were separated into three groups: handled, saline-treated, and TMX-treated. However, the n was quite small for a number of the groups, including various treatment groups. The handled mice were only handled for 10 seconds per day, while the treatment groups were injected daily with either TMX or saline. I would argue that during these daily injections, the mice endured the same amount of stress as did the handled mice. The mice were then assessed for anxiety-like behavior in the Elevated Plus Maze Task. Seven mice were excluded from the data following this task including those that were immobile for >40% of the time, though I wonder if this type of behavior might also be an indicator of anxiety. In general, I think there are a lot of factors that could influence exploratory behavior and that this behavioral assay should be taken with a grain of salt.
In regard to the proliferation of cells in the dentate gyrus, I'm curious as to why Figure 4 shows a significant increase in % of co-localization between BrdU+ and Tuj1+ cells in the saline-treated fathers as compared to saline-treated virgins but there is no significant increase in the number of BrdU-labeled cells between these groups in Figure 3. I was also confused as to why the number of proliferating cells can be directly compared between paternal mice and virgins -- if fatherhood begets neurogenesis, then wouldn't you expect more proliferating cells? In other words, I feel like Figure 3 should have been presented as a percentage of proliferating cells instead of absolute numbers in case the rate of neurogenesis is different between paternal mice and virgins. Overall, I think the paper did a convincing job of showing that there is neurogenesis in the hippocampus of paternal mice mediated by estrogen and its receptor which is not present in virgin mice.
I was also a little perplexed at the way they presented and interpreted their colocalization data--we'll talk about that today
ReplyDelete