Monday, September 23, 2019

Journal Club 2- Estrogen-dependent pathways in mediating neurogenesis

This paper outlined an interesting link between the endocrine and nervous systems, ultimately proving the potential for estrogen-dependent pathways in mediating hippocampal adult neurogenesis. It addresses this using a unique sample population as most mammalian species do not involve males in the parenting process. Unsurprisingly, parental postpartum behavior is often researched using the female brain while male postpartum behavior is not very researched on its own.  What I found fascinating about the results of these experiments was that despite having no role in parturition and lactation, they undergo similar neuroendocrine changes that accompany parenthood as females do. Furthermore, the fact that this paper addresses the neuroendocrine mechanisms underlying paternal experience-related hippocampal plasticity and suggests a parallel between the female and male brains is groundbreaking. 
Investigating Figure 1, I was surprised to see that paternal experience reduced prlr expression.  I was puzzled to see that the levels of prolactin, a hormone that binds to this receptor and involved with lactation were so high in the male virgin control group. I wonder how prolactin works to onset parental care and why its levels drop immediately postpartum. It would be interesting to perform similar experiments further examining the role of this hormone and what affect, if any, it may have on neuronal plasticity. 
What I also found interesting was that while there seemed to be a step-wise decline in estradiol levels from PND2 to PND30, an upregulation in ERB relative gene expression was observed at PND16. This is not what I expected as if the levels of estradiol are declining for most of the postpartum period, why is it that receptor expression for the hormone is so high? I assume that this may further affirm the claim that estradiol has a greater purpose than guiding parental behaviors in the postpartum period, and may very well enhance structural plasticity within the hippocampus.  It is also possible that activation of these receptors at PND16 may have underlied the increased adult neurogenesis observed in the saline-treated fathers since this effect was not observed in theTMX-treated fathers of experiment 2. It would be interesting to replicate this study using other selective estrogen related modulators to see whether these mechanisms may possibly be related to hormone-dependent cancers. 
The experimental design for experiment one was well thought out and the method of reverse RNA transcription and qPCR amplification was well controlled, with the efficiency of each primer and probe determined taken into consideration. However, something that I noted was that the standard deviations for the data in experiment one are fairly large.  Expression of Esr2 at PND16 had a variance of 0.23 which is about half of the mean, 0.44. The mean for Esr2 expression at PND30 was also about twice the value of the standard deviation, making the data very variable. This may be due to the very small sample sizes in this experiment.  For example, some hippocampal samples did not yield usable RNA in experiment one and were excluded from analyses, resulting in varied sample sizes across gene expression analyses. Had more mice been used in the experiments, I believe that the results would provide more precise and meaningful data. 
Although the paper noted two other studies suggesting that estradiol may support adult neurogenesis in the DG of parentally-behaving rodents, there are still many unanswered questions regarding the role of enhanced circulating estradiol and upregulation of specific estradiol receptors on the patterns of neurogenesis. Despite this, the paper proved that changes in estrogen receptor expression affect neurogenesis in fathers but not in virgin males. This important link between hormones and the brain points to a new avenue of research within neurogenesis as well as highlights the potential for possible treatments of hormone-related diseases. 

1 comment:

  1. Nice job noticing the difference in variability--that certainly is an issue. And I was also surprised that the ER time course did not follow the E2 time course

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.