Monday, September 23, 2019

Journal Club 2 - Response


Overall, I thought this paper was a more focused look at a specific topic relating to paternal neuroendocrine function and had fewer experiments that were tailored to the researchers’ hypothesis. The assays were more specific compared to the last paper we read and had fewer variables to manipulate and test for. This made for a slightly more in-depth study, with specific conclusions drawn from limited assays, as opposed to the last paper, which was broader and had more of a wider range of results and experiments. I thought that this was appropriate, as the previous paper seemed a bit more exploratory, while this paper was supported by previous experiments with similar results.
However, one issue I had with this paper was its use of figures and tables – specifically, in the way they listed some statistical information regarding their behavioural assays in table format. It made it very difficult to read and understand, and I think graphs with error bars would have made for easier reading rather than having to parse through the columns of the tables. In addition, I thought their results section was very statistic-heavy, using words like ‘significant interaction’ and ‘main effect’ that I thought were harder to put into context. This made it hard to interpret the results of the experiments, leaving me confused about what they were actually able to prove. I understood eventually that this was just the nature of the experiment, and that some of the assays they ran had a different effect between virgins and parents – for example, in the administration of the tamoxifen drug, there were different responses between parents who did and did not receive the drug as well as differences between controls and parents who did receive the drug. This ‘double result’ assay made for a little bit harder interpretation, but eventually I was able to understand what the authors were talking about (I think, I could be completely wrong).
            Another issue I had with the study was the number of animals that they needed to exclude from analysis for a variety of reasons, whether it was brain slices that needed to be excluded from assays, or poor behavioural responses from animals that led to them being removed from analysis. While I understand that problems may occur throughout experimentation, they had n values as high as 13 being excluded from particular studies, which made me wonder whether there was a bigger issue to be addressed with the assays that were being used. In addition, when it came to their estradiol concentration assay, the authors write that ‘concentrations did not meet assumptions of normality’ and decided to normalise the values instead. If there was also an issue with the estradiol quantification, I would again question their assay of choice rather than normalise the values to find results. Together, these results make me slightly worried about the care that the authors put into choosing assays, and whether or not they were fishing for results and changing the way they analyse data.

1 comment:

  1. Yes, they did exclude quite a few subjects, and their group sizes were pretty different from each other...good job noticing that

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.