This week I read the article titled “pubertal immune stress transiently
alters spatial memory processes in adulthood.” The article described an experiment
looking for a link between pubertal stress exposure via, LPS, gonad-derived hormone
modulation and cognitive spatial memory processing. The introduction does a
good job at describing the important activational effects of sex hormones as
well as the influence of immune stress during development and how these two may
interact.
I found it interesting that this article addressed the age
of the mice when they were transported to the lab, and that it stated that the
age was resistant to the enduring effects of shipping stress. Given the amount
of studies that have linked adolescent stress to later cognitive or psychiatric
impairment, I wonder how valid this is. I also wonder why this was not
addressed in any of the previous studies which we read, and if it could have
influenced those results.
With the Barnes Maze, I am unsure of the purpose of placing
the mice in the opaque chamber and exposing this to aversive stimuli, when the
test also aimed to “reduce potential anxiety.” I am also slightly confused as
to why both the Barnes Maze and the Morris Water Maze were used. I suppose that
it would be good to have two experimental measures, but they both seem to
measure spatial memory. Additionally, could the cognitive flexibility assessed
by the MWM just as easily have been assessed by reversing the BM? This would
avoid the additional stress which is caused by the MWM which has been shown to
influence learning/navigational behavior. Maybe this would be worth trying if
the experiment were repeated/replicated.
Most of the results seemed somewhat confusing to me. For
example in the open field test, LPS-SHAM females cover significantly less
distance than SAL-SHAM females, but yet move at a significantly faster pace. The
data for the Barnes maze was also slightly confusing. The maze graphs were
slightly complicated to read, with the significance of differences between the groups
being denoted by letters on a line graph.
I was initially surprised by the results of the MWM especially
given the effects of LPS on the BM performance, but possible explanations for
this were addressed in the discussion. The results of the MWM also mostly lined
up with the cellular expression data, which showed that most of the Ki67 and
DCX expression in the hippocampus was not significantly different between groups.
It was definitively good to read a paper were the main hypothesis was largely
not found to be true, as I am sure this is the case more often than I realize.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.