This study by Kolmogorova et al. first looked at whether a pubertal immune challenge by LPS influences hippocampal development and function in adulthood. Additionally, the group looked at the regulatory links between gonadal steroid hormones and hippocampus dependent memory functions after pubertal immune challenge. This was achieved by injecting pubertal mice with either LPS or saline (control), and then subjecting them to either gonadectomy or sham-surgery 3 weeks later. All mice groups were then evaluated by behavioral testing in the Barnes maze and Morris water maze to determine the extent of influence on spatial learning memory.
Overall, the researchers hypothesized that the LPS exposure during puberty would indeed produce sex-specific effects on hippocampus-dependent memory in adulthood, and that gonadectomy would impair cognitive performance in both sexes. The researchers determined that during low-stress spatial memory tasks, immune challenge by LPS during puberty impairs learning in both sexes, with females showing greater impairments in cognitive flexibility than males. However, LPS administration did not produce learning deficits in high-stress conditions and appear to occur independently of gonadal hormone influences. Additionally, males also show more sensitivity to LPS-priming of CA1 cellular proliferation than females, but LPS-induced changes in hippocampal neurogenesis was not seen in either sex. Overall, the findings did not support the initial hypothesis that gonadal steroid hormones impact performance or regulate the cognitive effects seen after pubertal LPS exposure.
One thing that immediately stood out to me about this study was the estrous phase determination by vaginal smear. The researchers noted the percentage of females in each phase and actively recognized that estrous cycles may impact the various measures they were testing based on previous research, but never looked specifically at whether performance differed depending on which phase the mice were in. Perhaps sampling them all together, rather than teasing apart individual differences, was used to show that when sampled as a group, no major differences in performance exist between estrous phases and that it is not a source of major variability to the extent that other papers believe it to be. However, I believe that the results would have benefited from including an additional figure depicting the performance of the females broken down by estrous phase. Perhaps no significant differences would be found, but I think establishing that fact is especially important when conducting research specifically pertaining to sex differences.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.