In this study by Kolmogorova et al, researchers aimed to establish whether exposure to an immune challenge during puberty would induce sex-specific deficits in behavioral and cellular indicators of hippocampus-dependent memory during adulthood. To do this, both male and female CD-1 mice were injected at six weeks of age with either saline or LPS to induce an immune response. Three weeks following, the mice were subjected to either gonadectomy or sham surgery. Then at ten weeks, the mice were subjected to a variety of behavioral tests including the open field, Barnes maze, and Morris water maze paradigms. Brain tissue was later collected at 17 weeks to examine cellular proliferation in the subgranular zone, CA1, and CA3 regions of the hippocampus.
The group concluded that LPS treatment during puberty impaired learning during adulthood in both male and female mice, but that hormonal modulation through gonadectomy did not mediate or alter any of these observations. The researchers also asserted that because learning deficits were more prominent in the Barnes maze than in the Morris water maze, LPS-induced cognitive impairments must have stress-dependent expression. They stated that LPS treatment seems to impair performance during low-stress (Barnes maze) but not high-stress (Morris water maze) conditions. I wasn't quite clear on what the purpose of using the Morris water maze was in this study, especially considering their mentioning that rat-based findings using this paradigm can't be translated to mice. I wasn't sure if their intention was to compare low-stress vs high-stress situations, or if this was a conclusion drawn after the study was completed as a way to explain differential behavior observed between the paradigms.
One question I had about the paper was whether the authors ever made any mention of group sizes (maybe I missed them?). Another question was why they chose 9 weeks for the gonadectomy and 17 weeks to collect brain tissue. The timing of both of these procedures was certainly a key factor in seeing results, so I wonder whether having completed these at different time points would have led to different observations. Lastly, I was wondering whether male and female mice go through puberty at the same time during their lives. In humans this is obviously not the case, so I wonder if differential pubertal timing in mice could have altered the effects of the LPS treatment and gonadectomy. Maybe time points for these procedures should actually be different between male and female mice?
Great points, Gabby--yes, rodent females DO go through puberty earlier than males, so I agree with you that is an important caveat.
ReplyDelete