Monday, October 7, 2019

Journal 3 - Probiotics and Inflammation-Associated Sickness Behavior

Overall, I found this to be a very interesting article. The relationship between the gut microbiome and the other systems in mammalian bodies is very fascinating to me. I did have a few questions as I was reading the methods of this article. Firstly, were there any real reasons why only male mice were used in this experiment? If there was, what were they? And if not, would using female mice as well be expected to yield results that were any different to what was found? 

Next, why were experiments performed 10 days after surgery? Was that simply when the mice were considered healed enough, and if so how was that determined? Relatedly, bacterial species treatment began 10 days before surgery. How was this date chosen? Additionally, I struggle slightly to believe sickness behavior results with only one social test (plus weight measures), and would have loved to see more behavioral tests on the mice.

The results appear to show that the oral VSL#3 treatment had no significant impact upon markers of liver injury and bowel permeability. Is it possible that if the experiment had been extended, this type of result would have been seen? I found myself slightly surprised with how short a period of time the mice underwent the experimental treatment, although I am aware that some microbiome changes can happen quite quickly. 

I did find it very interesting how, while probiotic consumption did not have major effects on the gut as I would have expected, it did still have impact upon the periphery-to-brain communication pathway. To me, this means that the gut and nervous system aren’t simply connected by a direct cause-and-effect relationship, but are likely rather simply factors that may be components of change within each other. I also love the implication that, in the future, psychiatric disorders may be able to be treated using a probiotic, and through treatment addressing multiple biological systems. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.