It’s been known that elevated corticosterone signaling and activated microglia result in increased neuroinflammatory responses after stress exposure in rodents, but this particular study wanted to further examine the role of sex differences in this process. I think this is a well designed paper with decently thought through experiments. I believe they are asking the right questions, but not testing it correctly. If you are measuring sex differences in response to stress, you must take into consideration the various stages of the estrous cycle. Were all the females in the same estrous stage? How did that impact their response to stress? Using an inescapable stress tail shock paradigm is common but also has its drawbacks. One of the many challenges is learned helplessness which is hard to compensate for. Is it possible that females are more persistent while males feel helpless in the situation? I know that any inescapable stress paradigm would make me feel pretty helpless. This study should use other methods of inducing stress and see how results compare. Things like a forced-swim should be avoided because that seems highly correlated with learned helplessness. Other confounding variables like sleep can also impact results. Overall, this paper does address very valid points and highlights the importance of sex differences in stress, but I think their approach and methods need a bit of work.
Great to see you on here Rodney-- very nice points. What do you mean by sleep as a confounding variable?
ReplyDelete