I
think this article really shows exactly how much information has been lost in
only studying male animal models of disease. Here, the authors show that the
pathway mediating stress in the two different sexes are different, and that
females have a markedly different biochemical reaction in their brains in response
to stress. This could potentially have implications for pharmacological treatment
of stress-related psychiatric disorders, seeing as there would be a new mechanism
of action to be targeted. For that reason, I think this paper is very important
and worth highlighting as evidence for why studies including both sexes are
absolutely necessary.
The
authors clearly outlined all their experiments, which in turn made it easier to
analyse their results, and I appreciated that. One thing that I was a bit
confused about was the number of groups – it was not always so clear in each
experiment how many groups there were and exactly who was getting what. I saw
in their methods that they had a very large number of rats that they used in
total (258), and so a clearer breakdown of the groups would have been helpful. Seeing
as there were multiple compound effects that the authors were testing, it would
have been better to do some sort of table to clearly define which treatments
certain groups were getting.
Overall,
I liked that the paper focused on the differences between males and females,
and that the authors dedicated a large number of experiments to not only prove
that there was a difference, but also to try and elucidate a mechanism to
explain why. In looking at the behavior, the male and female animals appeared
similar in response, which is probably one of the reasons why a more detailed
look at the differences between the sexes was never attempted. If they look the
same and act the same, why wouldn’t people assume that they are the same? But
this paper actually delves into the mechanism behind the neuroinflammatory response
to stress, and I think it was a very well done experiment that should inspire
further experiments to analyse the cellular differences in male and female response
to other paradigms, such as chronic stress or chronic fatigue.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.