This week I read the article title Stress-Induced neuroinflammatory
priming is time of day dependent. In general, the article examined the
differences between neuroinflammation between rats exposed to a stressor during
the light cycle and animals exposed to a stressor during the dark cycle. Overall,
I thought that the experiment did a good job of using multiple measures to
assess the effects of circadian rhythm on neuroinflammation.
The introduction/background section in my opinion could have
been more detailed and could specifically have included more information included
later in the discussion. For example, the discussion section included
additional information on what the actual proteins measured on the microglia
were responsible for, and how measuring their RNA was relevant to microglial
activation. If this had been included in the introduction it would have made
interpreting those results easier the first time around. However, the more
general important aspects were clearly introduced. The background section on
glucocorticoids was particularly interesting to me because of its relevance to
my mock grant proposal methods. I had initially considered using
glucocorticoids as a treatment to reduce neuroinflammation, however this
article discussed that it could actually potentiate inflammatory responses which
could conflict results. The overall effects that circadian rhythm had on the
brain also made me think about the microglial alterations and depressive
symptoms article that we read, where behavioral tests were performed during the
dark cycle which I though could cause altered results due to the disrupted
circadian rhythm.
As is the case with most of the articles we have read, all
the animals used were male which we have already discussed but is still worth
bringing up. I was unsure what the study meant when it said that the LPS dose
resulted in a sub-threshold hippocampal pro-inflammatory response. As neuroinflammation
is what was being measured I would assume that the inflammatory response should
be above threshold, so this confused me a little. Additionally, the use of a
reverse light dark cycle is definitively a convenient way to line up the experimental
treatment and tissue collection, however I was curious as to how long the rats
were given to adjust to this reversal. I was also curious as to how long it takes
corticosterone levels in the blood to change, as in experiment four the blood
samples were collected immediately after IS or HCC treatment so results may
have been different if the timing was different.
The results clearly showed that neuroinflammation priming
was influenced by the time of day that the stressor was applied. This was seen
in IL-B1 response and gene expression, and in IL-6 gene expression. However, the
experiments aimed at determining a mechanism did not really find significant
differences. I was surprised that there was not difference in the phenotype of
microglia isolated at different times, and that there was no significant
difference in the corticosterone concentration at the different times. These seem
to be the most obvious mechanisms for the differences in neuroinflammation
priming so I would have expected there to be significant differences.
nice points Kilian--typically labs will operate on a reversed light-dark cycle as their SOP, so the animals are always living in that environment and would only need to be habituated to the environment when they are first shipped (which needs to happen regardless of the light-dark cycle used)
ReplyDelete