Tuesday, December 3, 2019

05 Sixth Journal Club: Positive mood on the day of influenza vaccination predicts vaccine effectiveness: A prospective observational cohort study


This study was interesting since it is one of the first studies on the effect of psychological and behavioral factors on vaccine-induced protective antibody response in the elderly “using a robust method.” However, there were some clear limitations to the study.

The very first point that I wanted to bring up was the fact that the strain of the vaccine that was used in the study was the same strain as the vaccination of the previous year. Although they did mention this in their discussions section, I wonder if they were able to repeat the study where the vaccination strain was different; also, the fact that all three strains remaining in the vaccine the same happened only twice, previously, was very interesting.

Another question I had was the I-PANAS-SF test simplification. The paper states that the assessment was shortened to make it less burdensome. I was wondering if this is something that occurs frequently in studies involving mood measurements. If not, would this lower the accuracy of the positive and negative mood measurement, which was the focus of this study.

Overall, I thought this paper is a great start to study the effects of behavioral and psychological factors on influenza vaccine in elderly, but there definitely are improvements that can be made.

First, the sample used for this study was very specific to one race. They did mention it in the paper, and when I double-checked the numbers, 97.8 percent of the sample was Caucasian. Although this would have made sense if the study was focusing on Caucasian, because the study was for the general elderly population, the sample being nearly 100 percent Caucasian puts a huge limit to the study.

Second, the study is diary-based. Although there really is no way of keeping track of individual behavior of every single individual for 6 weeks, the fact that the behavioral data were all collected by diary makes it difficult for me to "buy" it. Especially because the study is on the elderly, the diary entry may not be as accurate as the researcher want them to be.

Lastly, I wanted to bring up the figures in the study. The paper is made up mostly of tables. This made it fairly difficult to understand what they wanted to present because every measurement they collected were included.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.