I found this type of paper interesting, as the researchers seem to admit that they were simply looking at numerous different factors that may influence flu vaccine outcomes. Most papers we read have hard, concrete hypotheses, whereas this one first gathered all the data and then looked for relationships between the variables to come to their conclusion. I appreciated how much thought went in to the project with all the background research they conducted and used to base their findings off of. However, I really did not "buy" the fact that positive mood on the day of vaccination increases the protective effects of the vaccine.
To start, basing half of the research project off of self-reporting diary entries that participants completed only three times a week leaves a lot of things unaccounted for. After working in a sleep research lab, I saw firsthand just how unreliable participant diaries can be, especially in regards to mood and perceived sleep quality. Mood is very subjective, and many individuals have different thresholds for what they consider "sad", "content", or "happy". Additionally, it is extremely difficult to track exactly what time you fall asleep, how long it takes to fall asleep, how many times you wake up at night, etc. These things combined can produce a large source of error into the data set. For that reason alone, I don't believe that a claim as strong as "positive mood on the day of vaccination is a significant predictor of seroprotection" can be made from the type of data collected.
This effect was also only found with the H1N1 strain, which is the least immuno-activating strain the group studied. Although interesting that this correlation is not seen with greater immune-activating strains, I would like to see additional follow-up evidence on why that may be happening before I believe that positive mood has any sort of influence.
All in all, I think this study could have benefited from measuring some other indicators of "mood" and stress. They mentioned in the paper that the group of participants were all relatively happy individuals, with very few reporting any stress or negative affect during the study period. Perhaps looking at something like waking cortisol or other blood hormones would be useful in gathering a more complete picture at exactly which factors are having the greatest influence.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.