I thought this paper was quite different from the ones we have previously read, in that it was quite exploratory and broad. I thought the premise of the study was interesting, especially considering the amount of background reading that the authors had done – it seemed like most of the results were confirming results that had been seen in other studies, and yet they still referred to this study as exploratory. I also thought the method of data collection was interesting. The authors defended their use of the diary method, saying that it was better than ‘retrospective self-report measures’, but I still think that this method leaves lots of room for error since they are asking participants to record every day. For the mood and affect data, it seems likely that a participant may have forgotten or made up a recording because they were busy or lazy, and this could skew results more than if the participants were simply asked to be reflective at a doctor’s appointment. However, I do think that this method was better for the dietary and sleep data, since that can be harder to remember over the course of many days. I also appreciated the authors’ explanations as to why they collected the data at the time points they did, and their reporting of data that was missing to show that there was in fact data missing that was insignificant and not attributable to any specific reason.
As for how much I ‘buy’ their results, I think they should be taken with a grain of salt. Positive and negative affect are measures that can be difficult to really quantify and measure since they are mostly abstract and vary greatly from person to person. For the authors to report that this measure, positive affect, was the only factor that had an impact on vaccination outcome seems shaky at best. Additionally, their potential reasoning that this could be caused by endocrine or lymphatic innervation seems questionable. If there was an endocrine reason, would this not be reflected by hormones or other endocrine signaling molecules in the blood samples of the participants? If the lymphatic system were innervated by the CNS, why were the results not similar across all different strains? This also brings me to another point, that which the authors note that the vaccination that the participants were receiving was the same exact vaccination that they had gotten the year before. This, to me, really invalidates the whole point of the study, seeing as some of the participants already had seroprotective levels of IgG in their blood prior to the vaccination as part of this study. How can the authors say that they are measuring the effect of the vaccination when it was mostly redundant at the time of the study? I think it would have been more beneficial to study the effects of these immune modulators on at least one novel strain, but that was not possible in this study. For that reason, I believe that this study should be repeated before results stating that ‘greater positive mood […] significantly predicted greater antibody responses to the influenza vaccination’ are to be believed.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.