Monday, December 2, 2019

Journal Club 5: positive mood on day of influenza vaccination

Within the article, the researchers sought to determine whether a positive mood on the day of vaccination would increase the effectiveness of the vaccine. Their objective was to observe the effects of multiple behavioral and psychological influences on the effectiveness of the immune response to influenza in adults 65 years of age and older.

What the researchers saw was that the greater the mood in older adults, particularly on the day of vaccination, the more the body effectively responded to the vaccination. I thought this was a particular interesting article, especially because there it is one of the first studies to examine all behavioral and psychological immune modulators and how they might influence vaccination responses simultaneously.

At first glance, the study I thought would be difficult to test all behavioral and psychological immune modulators being that there are so many different factors. In measuring positive and negative mood I thought it was interesting that they only assessed their mood based on four responses in the diary period, 2 positive and two negative, I would think that it would not be enough to determine an individuals over all mood to be positive of negative. In addition, because the data collected is from the individual themselves the information given could be biased. Another problem I saw was that all of the individuals were from the same area. Racial and genetic factors could also play a role in the immune response. Lastly, I feel like it might be difficult to fully say whether the vaccine is effective if the individual is not exposed to the influenza virus.

There were a couple things I was confused about in the experiment. I had a hard time figuring out how they merged all the data together and well as Figure 3. I think an interesting factor that could have added in is exercise since they discussed another study found that exercise before a vaccination showed greater post-vaccination antibodies. Lastly, I thought it was interesting that only the weakest strain, H1N, and the relationship between positive mood and antibody responses was observed. It would be interesting to see what factors might increase the effectiveness of H3N2 and B immunogenic strains.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.